Stephen Wolframstephenwolfram.com
Publications by Stephen Wolfram * Articles * Particle Physics * Positivity Constraints on Quark and Gluon Distributions in QCD (1978)
Positivity Constraints on Quark and Gluon Distributions in QCD (1978)


4. Analytic Results

It is expected [4] that the effects of operators occurring in the operator product expansion with twists greater than two become very important for , corresponding to (terms of higher order in also diverge in the limit at fixed , but this is only significant at much larger values of ). Starting distributions need only be rejected, therefore, if they lead to negative distributions for (). Nevertheless, as explained in sect. 1, it is interesting to consider the limit , where we find

where

For , the factor is negative. The distributions therefore become negative unless the first terms in eq. (10a) dominate as . Making the assumption of eq. (2) for the behaviour of the starting distributions as and behave like and , respectively, for large . Eq. (3) is then the condition that and remain positive for . If the inequalities of eq. (3) are satisfied, remains positive for all but still becomes negative for sufficiently small. For this occurs at

As stated in sect. 1, it is clear that distributions for generated from any starting distributions must obey eq. (3). When at fixed ,

so that eq. (10a) shows that : but in general this will only become true at extremely high when the structure functions will all be infinitesimal for close to one. To make more useful statements about the form of the structure functions for , we must assume a particular form for the starting distributions. If, for example, following ref. [5], we take for , then, ignoring terms, eqs. (10) and (4) give for .

Next we consider the moments. The energy-momentum sum rule implies , so that for the singlet structure functions

Hence will inevitably become negative as , unless , in which case will become negative. In fig. 1 we have plotted the value of below which or becomes negative (which we call as a function of ) for and (the results are very insensitive to the number of flavours). The very reasonable demand that requires ) , (experimentally ) and if (by which point higher-twist operators should be becoming significant for ), .



[ Figure 1 ] The value of below which the predicted total momenta carried by the gluons (lower line) or quarks (upper line) becomes negative, as a function of the momentum carried by the gluons at ( and ).



[ Figure 2 ] The value of below which the predicted total momentum carried by one flavour of antiquark becomes negative, as a function of the momentum it carried at for various starting gluon momenta, ) ( and ).

The value of at which becomes negative is easily calculated from eq. (4) as a function of and using the fact that and (which has already been used in deriving eq. (11)). The results are shown in fig. 2 for and (they are insensitive to ). The reasonable demand that gives ) for and implies . Neutrino data suggest that not greatly in excess of this bound. For strange quarks the bound probably fails with but larger is needed for it to be credible in this case. However, our bounds show that the distributions of new flavours must be non-zero in regions of where the application of asymptotic freedom formulae to them is at all reasonable.

Figs. 1 and 2 show that the observed values of and are obtained if and vanish at . This was originally pointed out in ref [5].

previous  l   next